RSS

Review: Cinder (Book 1 in The Lunar Chronicles series)

07 Oct
Image

Book Cover: Catalan Edition cover. Only slightly different then the English cover but I like the blue slipper better

Cinder (Book 1 in The Lunar Chronicles series)

By: Marissa Meyer

Published: January 3, 2012

Company: Feiwel & Friends

Language: English

This young adult series takes a spin on the classic Cinderella fairy tale in a futuristic dystopian set sometime after World War IV. This book’s heroine is Linh Cinder, a cyborg teen and only full-service mechanic at New Beijing’s weekly market, struggling to live under the roof of her evil step-mother Linh Adri and step-sisters Pearl and Peony. Well, to be fair, Peony is the good step-sister while Pearl is the bad step-sister.

I’m not going to bother to summarize the whole story. If you’ve seriously NEVER heard the story of Cinderella, go look up on Wikipedia.

Don’t worry. We’ll wait for you to catch up.

Ready? Excellent!!

Now Cinder is based off Cinderella, however Marissa takes her own spin on it, adding new elements to it: such as the outbreak of Letumosis that’s ravaging the Earth, the second class treatment of cyborgs and Androids, an injection of Asian culture (without it being racist or questionable), and political tensions with Luna. It should be worth pointing out that Cinder is NOT white! Yup, that’s right. Our main character is female, cyborg, and of Asian-decent, and the Asian point isn’t hit over the head for the readers. No stereotypes for her (or her step family). Even though I’m white, it’s nice to have a young adult series with a non-white heroine character.

Another thing that I enjoyed while reading this was that Cinder’s character was not being driven by the need to find a boyfriend and/or to fall in love. Nope, not a primary motivator for her. Instead she is motivated at first to escape her step family and discover more about her origins, as she has no memories of her life before becoming a cyborg. All she knows about her previous life is what was told to her. She has no photos of her parents (or names for that matter), no personal mementos from her past life, or even a last name. What’s driving her is self-discovery: who am I, where did I come from, and what can I do with my life. These issues are something anyone can relate to, regardless of age. Yes, Cinder falls in love with a Prince (though that’s another issue all together), but even this doesn’t cause her to deviate from her own path. Even in the second book as her relationship with the Prince progresses, that relationship doesn’t become a higher priority than her self-discovery and this is something I find refreshing.

I very much enjoyed the tone and language of the novel. Despite not being the target audience (a 13 – 15 year old teenager, probably female), I never felt like I was being talked down to or talked at, but rather I was being treated as an equal member of the audience. I suppose we get this from the story from being told from Cinder’s point of view, as opposed to a nameless narrator, but even with Cinder’s sarcastic attitude, we could have had Cinder talking down to the audience about certain aspects of her world that we’re unfamiliar with.

What I wished to read more about in the novel was about the city of New Beijing and this new post-World War VI era. We’re never really told what caused the previous (or even third one) war or the outcomes or how this new world is divided, as we get a small introduction later to the other world political leaders. I’m not sure if this is because we will learn more about this later in the series or if this is something we’re just supposed to fill in on our own, but with this being the first book in the series, I would have liked to have gotten some background information about this.

I found this novel refreshing and quiet enjoyable to read. So much so that I plowed through this and straight on to Book 2, Scarlet, in the same sitting! If you’re concerned about the science fiction element (as some people can find that to be overwhelming at times), it doesn’t delve deep into it as you would in something like Star Trek. The story still takes place on Earth, there is no long sentences of techno-babble, and I suspect the science parts we get is more to sound really cool and interesting and less reality based. Though I say that last point as someone who does not have a science background in any way so I apologize if I’m wrong or offend anyone. Definitely a great read for a teenager just stepping into (junior) high school but can be enjoyed by those who’ve long since left their high school days.

So what do you think about this first book in the series? Agree with me? Disagree? Leave your comments below and I’ll happily respond. Also if you have any suggestions for me for future reviews, leave them in the comments.

Advertisements
 
9 Comments

Posted by on October 7, 2013 in Review

 

Tags: , , , , ,

9 responses to “Review: Cinder (Book 1 in The Lunar Chronicles series)

  1. smhelland

    October 8, 2013 at 10:35 PM

    Great first review! My favorite part: “I’m not going to bother to summarize the whole story. If you’ve seriously NEVER heard the story of Cinderella, go look up on Wikipedia.” Made me laugh!

    I’ve seen this book around, but I thought it was just a modern-day Cinderella story so I didn’t pick it up. It sounds really interesting though!

     
    • Cookie Book Lover

      October 9, 2013 at 7:41 PM

      The series is really good. They’re more then just a twist on the classic Princesses. I’m REALLY looking forward to Cress, which will introduce our cyber-hacker twist on Rapunzel 😀 Though I’m REALLY hoping that she doesn’t get paired off with someone cause otherwise that would just get repetitive as hell ~_~

       
  2. mdickeson

    October 9, 2013 at 7:24 PM

    Nice review! I read Cinder earlier this year and enjoyed it a fair bit.

    I liked that it keeps the structure of the Cinderella tale enough for the fact it’s a retelling to matter, but very much shapes that structure to keep things at least a little unpredictable and complicated. The villain I found kinda one-note eeeeeeeeeeevil, but based on how the book ends there’s a lot of room for that to grow in the remaining three books. I hope I manage to get back to the series one day!

    Interestingly, not only is the romance plot never privileged over the other elements of Cinder’s personal growth at all, as you point out, but the prince as a character is very much playing second fiddle. He’s important, and he’s interesting — well, a bit, sometimes –, but this is Cinder’s show. I really appreciated that the book never lost sight of this.

     
    • Cookie Book Lover

      October 9, 2013 at 7:38 PM

      Yeah, I found the Prince to be rather flat and was okay with the main villain (it was never really about her anyways). They might give her more development later but we shall see. I think you would really enjoy the second book, Scarlet, and the side-story before Scarlet, The Queen’s Army. But read the side-story AFTER Scarlet, since it does reveal some things about one of the characters they introduce in that book.

       
  3. mdickeson

    October 12, 2013 at 2:35 PM

    I didn’t know about “The Queen’s Army”, thanks! Where is it? Is it online? I know there’s a short story set prior to Cinder, “Glitches”, up on tor.com.

    I’ll definitely try and get back to the second book. I just read the blurb for Cress and it sounds very fun. Since I tend to read more young adult fantasy when I read young adult, it’s nice to know there’s a good ya science fiction series waiting.

     

Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: